Generations Of Folk, Vol. 4: The Troubadors

Generations Of Folk, Vol. 4: The Troubadors

Generations Of Folk, Vol. 4: The Troubadors

Editorial Reviews
Amazon.com
The subtitle of volume 4 of Vanguard's Generations of Folk series is "The Troubadours," but here's an alternate suggestion: "Artists Who Didn't Fit on Any Other Anthology." This haphazardly compiled collection features the likes of Don McLean ("American Pie"), Cat Stevens ("Wild World"), Richie Havens ("Here Comes the Sun"), and Rick Nelson ("Garden Party"). Then there are middle-of-the-road types such as Stephen Bishop and Michael Johnson, the more left-field likes of Paul Kelly and Peter Case, and even a movie star (Keith Carradine) thrown in for good measure. The problem with this 12-track anthology is that there doesn't seem to be a unifying theme, unless guys with guitars qualifies. If you're dying to have several singer-songwriter hits on one disc, consider The Troubadours, but most folks are better advised to mosey on down the road and find themselves a more finely honed collection, such as one of Rhino's Troubadours of the Folk Era collections. --Steven Stolder

Generations Of Folk, Vol. 4: The Troubadors,Various Artists,Vanguard Records,AM Pop,Folk & Traditional,Folk-Rock,Pop,Pop/Rock,Singer/Songwriter,Soft Rock,Traditional Folk
Generations Of Folk, Vol. 4: The Troubadors
Average customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars
  • Not exactly the folk singers you think of as troubadors
Generations Of Folk, Vol. 4: The Troubadors
Various Artists
Manufacturer: Vanguard Records
ProductGroup: Music
Binding: Audio CD

GeneralGeneral | Folk | Styles | Music
Traditional FolkTraditional Folk | Folk | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Compilations | Folk | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Pop | Styles | Music
Singer-SongwritersSinger-Songwriters | Pop | Styles | Music
Soft RockSoft Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
Pop RockPop Rock | Pop | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Oldies | Pop | Styles | Music
CompilationsCompilations | Pop | Styles | Music | Dance Pop | Easy Listening | General | Oldies | Traditional Vocalists
Folk RockFolk Rock | Rock | Styles | Music
GeneralGeneral | Folk | Indie Music | Stores | Music
Similar Items:
  1. Generations of Folk, Vol. 2: Protest & Politics
  2. Generations Of Folk, Vol. 1: Festivals Of Folk
  3. Generations Of Folk, Vol. 3: Classic Harmonies

ASIN: B00000AE5M
Release Date: 1998-09-15

Tracks:

  1. American Pie - Don McLean
  2. Wild World - Cat Stevens
  3. On And On - Stephen Bishop
  4. Let Me Fall - Peter Case
  5. Beautiful In My Eyes - Joshua Kadison
  6. Here Comes The Sun - Richie Havens
  7. Bluer Than Blue - Michael Johnson
  8. Garden Party - Rick Nelson
  9. I'm Easy - Keith Carradine
  10. Walking To China - John Jennings
  11. Sing A Song For You - Tim Buckley
  12. Deeper Water - Paul Kelly

Amazon.com

The subtitle of volume 4 of Vanguard's Generations of Folk series is "The Troubadours," but here's an alternate suggestion: "Artists Who Didn't Fit on Any Other Anthology." This haphazardly compiled collection features the likes of Don McLean ("American Pie"), Cat Stevens ("Wild World"), Richie Havens ("Here Comes the Sun"), and Rick Nelson ("Garden Party"). Then there are middle-of-the-road types such as Stephen Bishop and Michael Johnson, the more left-field likes of Paul Kelly and Peter Case, and even a movie star (Keith Carradine) thrown in for good measure. The problem with this 12-track anthology is that there doesn't seem to be a unifying theme, unless guys with guitars qualifies. If you're dying to have several singer-songwriter hits on one disc, consider The Troubadours, but most folks are better advised to mosey on down the road and find themselves a more finely honed collection, such as one of Rhino's Troubadours of the Folk Era collections. --Steven Stolder

Customer Reviews:

4 out of 5 stars Not exactly the folk singers you think of as troubadors.......2004-01-27

Volume 4, "The Troubadors," is the weakest in the "Generations of Folk" series and the one that goes the farthest afield from the roots and essence of the American folk revival. For the holidays I was burning folk compilations for friends and family, and on this album there was only one song that I had included, which was Richie Haven's cover of George Harrison's "Here Comes the Sun." Of course I have Don McLean's "American Pie," which I have to admit I had never really thought of as a folk song before, and Ricky Nelson's "Garden Party," which I always thought of as being a Country & Western song. The same goes for Keith Carradine's Oscar winning song "I'm Easy," from the film "Nashville." Those songs clearly point out the direction of this particular collection, which goes so far as to include Tim Buckley's "Sing a Song for You," which is basically a folk-jazz song. But Stephen Bishop's "On and On" is really just soft rock.

Beyond those hits there are a lot of songs that I am not sure that I had ever heard before: Peter Case's "Let Me Fall," Joshua Kadison's "Beautiful in My Eyes," Micheal Johnson's "Bluer Than Blue," John Jennings' "Walking to China," and Paul Kelly's "Deeper Water." These are all decent songs, but when you suggest troubadors and the topic is folk music I immediately think of Woody Guthrie and then we are talking Pete Seeger. Nobody else on this collection would even have been included on my short list, so that tended to put these songs in a lesser light just for that reason. But this one also falls short on the standard test for song collections, which is that you can five songs you do not have worth the adding. The main reason to pick up this one is because you already have the other three volumes of the "Generations of Folk" series.

Music Review:

  1. Half Wild
  2. Hear Our Prayer
  3. Herrings in the Bay
  4. Holy Modal Rounders
  5. Hop On Pretty Girls
  6. House Full: Fairport Convention Live at the LA Troubadour [Live] [Original recording remastered] [Import]
  7. In a Time of Overstatement
  8. In the Land of Dreams
  9. Irish Christmas Rollick
  10. Jimmie Rodgers Sings Folk Songs/The Folk Song World of Jimmie Rodgers [Original recording remastered] [Import]

Music Review

music review

Recommended Music:

Die 20 Schönsten Weihnachtslieder

Kantorow & Gifford Duo at Belton House

Piano Chamber Music

Hot Piano! Ragtime Blues Jazz Classical Mark Birnbaum

Open [Import]

Music Evolution

Never Shall Forget [Live]

Monologue

New Classic Waylon

La Ultima Noche en la Tierra

One in a Million

Mototronic [Import]

Media Nation V.2 [Import]

Mozart: Arias

Rumba Para Monk