| 1. Twelve |
| 2. Water Wheel |
| 3. Perca Mundo |
| 4. Piano Tapestry |
| 5. Anniversary |
| 6. Procession |
| 7. Star Cluster |
| 8. Tiger Chimes |
| 9. Red Panda |
| 10. Cats Dancing |
| 11. Return to Water Wheel |
| 12. Waiting (for Katara) |
Editorial Reviews
contemporary jazz instrumental piano & chamber orchestra: twelve, eleven nine, eight cycle & play harmonic overtones sparkle above symphonic water wheel perca mundo piano tapestry cascading, hands intertwine, change rhythms anniversary: our tenth procession: Peruvian birds to African rhinos, rhythms of the forest intensify, then silence as each approach water wheel harmonics return in a star cluster, spiraling through the night sky tiger chimes: Asian cat approaches; shall we respect her with ceremony or quickly exit her presence red pandas coon to a diatonic scale; winds swirl as flutes through branches of their homes cats dancing, as the neighborhood sleeps, felines sleek out to dance & play return: full cycle through the large wooden wheel, black swan approaches waiting: we know she's coming; she may be about to be born, but we can do little to embrace our Sichuan daughter prior to the destined time intruments: upright bass, shakuhatchi, winter bells, water wheel, perca mundo, piano, violin, tiara blues, french horn,
wind,
cymbals, cello, flugle flute, vibes, oohs & ahs, andes flute, crotales, timpani
Water Wheel,Ken Ziegler,DesignTalk Studios,contemporary jazz instrumental piano, percussion & chamber orchestra
Average customer rating:
|
Dvorák: The Masterworks [Box Set]
Manufacturer: Brilliant Classics ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00062FLJW Release Date: 2004-11-30 |
Customer Reviews:
breakdown by cd........2007-01-14
CD8:PIANO CONCERTO
CD9:VIOLIN CONCERTO & CELLO CONCERTO
CD10-11:REQUIEM
CD12-13:STABAT MATER
CD14:PIANO TRIOS OP.90 "DUMKY" & 21
CD15:PIANO TRIOS OP.65 & 26
CD16:PIANO QUARTETS
CD17:PIANO QUINTETS
CD18:STRING QUINTETS
CD19-20:MUSIC FOR VIOLIN AND PIANO
C21:SERENADE/HAUSMUSIK
CD22-31:THE COMPLETE STRING QUARTETS
CD32:SLAVONIC DANCES OP.46 & 72
CD33:PIANO DUET SLAVONIC DANCES
CD34:PIANO DUET LEGENDS FROM THE BOHEMIAN FOREST
CD35:PIANO WORKS
CD36-37:RUSALKA
CD38-40:SYMPHONIC POEMS
I'm not a music expert.......2005-08-25
Now, here's what you'll get in this box set, seeing as Amazon does not give it a description. 40 cds! no joke, you get 40 cds in this box set. It features:
1. Complete symphonies
2. Complete symphonic poems
3. Cello concerto
4. Piano concerto
5. Violin concerto
6. Requiem
7. Stabat Mater
8. Slavonic Dances
9. Complete String quartets
10. Chamber music
11. Piano Works (solo and duet)
12. Rusalka
As far as I can tell, the only things missing are The Spectre's Bride and Jacobin. Seeing as it is 40 cds, i have not had an opportunity to listen to it, however what i have heard i have been quite satisfied with.
Average customer rating:
|
Dvorak: Symphonic Poems
Manufacturer: Chandos ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00000IM6P Release Date: 1999-04-13 |
Tracks:
- Overture: My Home, Op. 62 - Dvorak
- The Water Goblin, Op.107 - Dvorak
- The Golden Spinning Wheel, Op.109 - Dvorak
Tracks:
- The Noon Witch, Op. 108 - A. Dvorak
- The Wood Dove. Op. 110 - A. Dvorak
- The Hero's Song, Op. 111 - A. Dvorak
Customer Reviews:
Maybe it is time to rethink these works.......2006-07-30
As it turns out, Dvorak returned to his home in Bohemia after the completion of the New World Symphony and set out to compose a series of symphonic poems based on tales from "The Garland," which contains a collection of Czech folk ballads. Four of Dvorak's symphonic poems are directly based on the grisly tales from this collection, while the final and fifth symphonic poem, "The Hero's Song" (Dvorak's final orchestral work) is based on Dvorak's general ideas about an adventurer setting out in the world.
First things first, this is some of greatest music of the Romantic tradition available. Each of these pieces contains the best elements of Dvorak's music: the orchestration is colorful, the tunes are distinctive, and the codas are some of the most exciting in classical music. Dvorak was clearly at his creative height when the symphonic poems were composed. What makes these pieces truly spectacular is Dvorak's vivid portrayal of the macabre stories from "The Garland." And the word "macabre" isn't used lightly here. These stories involve decapitations, murders, witches and goblins.
The first symphonic poem "The Water Goblin" concerns a goblin who forces a girl, who has fallen into a lake, to live with him in the watery depths. The girl's only consolation is her half-goblin baby. Eventually, the girl escapes, but the goblin finds her and kills the baby. Not really a happy story, but Dvorak's depiction of all of these events is masterful. The goblin theme is menacing, the girl's lament is lovely, and the gruesome events concluding the story are depicted in dramatic fashion by the orchestra. The CD notes by Gerald Larner are extremely detailed and explain the stories much better than I have with "The Water Goblin" above. Further the notes reconcile Dvorak's musical ideas to the story in a manner which anyone can understand.
I won't try to describe the remaining symphonic poems, as the stories are far too detailed and I probably couldn't do the music justice. Suffice it to say, the remaining pieces are fabulous. And despite the long length of these works ("The Golden Spinning Wheel" is 27 minutes long) there is not a dull moment. As a side note, the earlier "My Home" overture opens the program and is included primarily as a filler. Nevertheless, the performance of that work is also great.
Given that Dvorak worked on these pieces simultaneously (they are labeled with contiguous opus numbers) and that they were based on stories from the same source, one could argue that the symphonic poems could be viewed as a single multi-movement work, perhaps a proramme symphony based on nationalistic elements. In such a work, "The Wood Dove" would constitute the adagio; "The Noon Witch" would probably be the scherzo; while "The Hero's Song" would serve as the finale, bringing the whole thing to a triumphant (emphasized) close. Of course, such an idea conflicts with the romantic idea that Dvorak wrote nine symphonies, with his dark and dramatic ninth being is crowning achievement.
All of that is hypothetical though. You just need to know that this release is a must classical music lovers. These works should be far better known and can stand as equals along side the best moments within Dvorak's symphonies. Get this disc, you won't be disappointed.
Highest recommendation!!
CD 1: 57:14
CD 2: 53:57
Arguably the Definitive Set of Dvorak Symphonic Poems.......2005-01-08
Fantastic performances.......2004-03-28
I have Kubelik's version on DG as well as these recordings. Although Kubelik does some very interesting things with the poems, bringing out nuances of the scores and delightful orchestral effects, he does not have the convection that Jarvi has. Rather, it sounds as if Kubelik is treating these works as inferior; he is not convinced by them. Jarvi, on the other hand, has totally immersed himself in the music of the Bohemian master, producing a complete traversal of the symphonies with the orchestra. And his love of Dvorak is evident here. Jarvi is completely aware of the charm and beauty of these works, as well as their musical importance. He performs these works smashingly, especially the Water Goblin, which he champions. The sound of the orchestra is warmer and smoother than Kubelik's performances. My only complaint would be that the orchestra does sound a bit distant in these recordings - the acoustics are not top notch. However, Jarvi's energy and belief in these works make this CD a must for any Dvorak lover.
Jarvi and the RSNO do Dvorak's glitter and gore proud!.......2000-10-19
Average customer rating:
|
Explorer: Nubia - Escalay the Water Wheel
Various Artists Manufacturer: Nonesuch ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B00006C75W Release Date: 2002-08-27 |
Tracks:
- The Water Wheel
- Remind Me
- Song With Tar
Amazon.com
When this set--part of the Nonesuch Explorer Series--was first released, Hamza El Din had already headlined at the Newport Folk Festival and Woodstock and released an album on the Vanguard label. But this was the one that put him on the map, bringing his oud (Arab lute,) tar (an ancient frame drum), and plaintive vocals to a much wider audience. Born in 1929, El Din has dedicated his life to the music of his ancestral homeland of Nubia, much of which now lies underwater in the shadow of the Aswan Dam. The title track, a 21-minute meditation based on the creaking, rhythmic sounds of a wooden water wheel, later became his signature work. Despite the unadorned simplicity of his forces, El Din evokes centuries of laboring agrarian workers. He later re-recorded the piece several times, including a version with the Kronos Quartet, but he has never quite duplicated the tidal ebb-and-flow of the original performance. --Christina RodenCustomer Reviews:
Bad ..........2003-04-08
Hard to put your finger on........2002-10-31
Nubia Revisted.......2002-10-15
Average customer rating:
|
Slavonic Dances / Overtures & Symphonic Poems
Dvorak , Brs , and Kubelik Manufacturer: Deutsche Grammophon ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000065TV2 Release Date: 2002-06-11 |
Customer Reviews:
Bohemian American Variegated Sounds.......2004-04-15
His Slavonic roots seem to leap out of this music in the Slavonic Dances, which are played here with robusto and eubilence by the Kubelik led Bavarian Radio Symphony.
This pious man who said that "he studied with the birds, flowers, God and myself" exerts in this collection a humility yet assertive control of his music, showing tranquility and robust outbursts of joy. The Hussite Overture was of real interest to this reviewer as not only is it passionately played as am quite of fan of this Bavarian reformer who truly was inspirational and foundational to Luther.
Their rendition of Carnival is electrifying and warm, especially the nature theme of the clarinets.
The Wood Dove is very much a mood swinger with is funeral dirge march catapulting into a marvelous love song and sweet violin solo.
Highly enjoyable recording.
Not played with total conviction.......2004-03-29
The dances, however, are delightfully played and recorded. Kubelik seems to be having fun while performing these lighthearted dance pieces, and his energy is evident in the recording, the quality of which is quite good. Although for the overtures I suggest Kertez with the London Symphony Orchestra and Neeme Jarvi with the Scottish National Orchestra for the symphonic poems, this is a delightful set for the dances. Recommendable.
The stuff is almost 30 years old.......2004-02-13
One of Dvorakýs finest recordings.......2003-10-07
This version of the Slavonic Dances is wonderfull. Actually, for me the only one that equals its quality is the Antal Dorati's with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra on Decca, which, by the way, happens to have a better sound than Kubelik's. Regarding the Symphonic Poems and the Overtures, you just won't find a better recording than this one, not to mention the fact of having all this works together. The sound is good, and the performances are outstanding.
a basic recommendation and a real bargain.......2002-07-15
Average customer rating: |
Tracing a Wheel on Water
Manufacturer: Aaron Larget-Caplan ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B000FTAP5G Release Date: 2005-01-01 |
Tracks:
- Six for a Dance by Lior Navok -world premiere
- Equinox by Toru Takemitsu
- Two Wind Dances, Mov. I -Dance of Zephyrus by Daniel Pinkham -world premiere
- Two Wind Dances, Mov. II- Dance of Boreas by Daniel Pinkham -world premiere
- Cancion de Cuna by Leo Brouwer
- Tracing a wheel on water by Kevin Siegfried -world premiere
- Ojos Brujos by Leo Brouwer
- El Abejorro by Emilio Pujol
- La Catedral, Mov. I- Preludio saudade by Agustin Barrios Mangore
- La Catedral, Mov. II- Andante religioso
- La Catedral, Mov. III- Allegro Solemne
- Tango en Skai by Roland Dyens
Album Description
Tracing a wheel on water features classical guitar solos of the last 100 years, six countries, & with various compositional styles, from energetic & twisted dance to folk lullaby and picturesque sounds of Latin America and more. Includes three World Premieres by Daniel Pinkham, Kevin Siegfried, & Lior Navok.
Average customer rating:
|
A Lonesome Road - Paul Robeson sings spirituals and songs
Manufacturer: Asv Living Era ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000001HFH Release Date: 1994-04-20 |
Tracks:
- Ol' Man River
- My Curly Headed Baby
- Water Boy
- I'm Goin' To Tell God All O' My Troubles
- Oh! Didn't It Rain
- Little Pal
- There's No Hiding Place
- Poor Old Joe
- Scandalize My Name
- Ezekiel Saw The Wheel
- Sinner, Please Don't Let This Harvest Pass
- Just Keepin' On
- Mah Lindy Lou
- Steal Away
- Mighty Lak' A Rose
- Deep River
- Hear The Lambs A-Cryin'
- Get On Board, Little Children
- Old Folks At Home (Swanee River)
- Witness
- Oh! Rock Me, Julie
- Li'L Gal
- I Got A Home In That Rock
- Lonesome Road
Customer Reviews:
Robeson at his best.......2001-03-24
Average customer rating:
|
Dvorák: The Complete Published Orchestral Works
Manufacturer: Naxos ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B0001FYRB2 Release Date: 2004-07-20 |
Tracks:
- Allegro
- Adagio Molto
- Allegretto
- Finale: Allegreto
- Allegretto
- Molto Moderato
- Allegro Giusto
- Molto Maestoso
- Allegro Giusto
Tracks:
- Allegretto
- Poco Adagio
- Scherzo: Allegro Con Brio
- Finale: Allegreto Con Fuoco
- Allegro Con Moto
- Allegretto Grazioso
- Un Poco Allegretto E Grazioso
- Andante Con Moto
- Andante
Tracks:
- Allegro Moderato
- Adagio Molto, Temp Di Marcia
- Allegro Vivace
- Allegro Non Tanto
- Adagio
- Scherzo: Furiant: Presto
- Finale: Allegro Con Spirito
Tracks:
- Allegro
- Andante Sostenuto E Molto Cantabile
- Scherzo: Allegro Feroce
- Finale: Allegro Con Brio
- Allegro Con Brio
- Adagio
- Allegretto Grazioso - Molto Vivace
- Allegro, Ma Non Troppo
Tracks:
- Allegro, Ma Non Troppo
- Andante, Con Moto
- Andante Con Moto, Quasi L'istesso Tempo - Allegro Scherzando
- Finale: Allegro Molto
- Allegro Maestoso
- Poco Adagio
- Scherzo Vivace - Poco Meno Mosso
- Finale: Allegro
Tracks:
- Adagio- Allegro Molto
- Largo
- olto Vivace
- Allegro Con Fuoco
- Sumphonic Variations, Op. 78
Tracks:
- Allegro Agitato - Jeno Jando
- Andante Sostenuto
- Allegro Con Fuoco
- The Water Goblin, Symphonic Poem, Op. 107
Tracks:
- Allegro Ma Non Troppo - Ilya Kaler
- Adagio Ma Non Troppo - Ilya Kaler
- Allegro Giocoso, Ma Non Troppo - Ilya Kaler
- Romance For Violin And Orchestra In F Minor, Op. 11 - Ilya Kaler
- Mazurka For Violin And Orchestra, Op. 49 - Alexander Trostianski
Tracks:
- Allegro - Maria Kliegel
- Adagio Ma Non Troppo - Maria Kliegel
- Finale: Allegro Moderato - Andante - Allegro Vivo - Maria Kliegel
- Walderuhe For Cello And Orchestra, Op. 68/5 - Dmitry Yablonsky
- Rondo For Cello And Orchestra, Op. 94 - Dmitry Yablonsky
Tracks:
- No. 1 In C Major
- No. 2 In E Minor
- No. 3 In A Flat Major
- No. 4 In F Major
- No. 5 In A Major
- No. 6 In D Major
- No. 7 In C Minor
- No. 8 In G Minor
- No. 1 In B Major
- No. 2 In E Minor
- No. 3 In F Major
- No. 4 In D Flat Major
- No. 5 In B Flat Minor
- No. 6 In B Flat Major
- No. 7 In C Major
- No. 8 In A Flat Major
Tracks:
- Rhapsody, Op. 14
- No. 1
- No. 2
- No. 3
Tracks:
- The Noon Witch, Op. 108
- The Golden Spinning-Wheel, Op. 109
- The Wild Dove, Op. 110
Tracks:
- Moderato
- Tempo Di Valse
- Scherzo: Vivace
- Larghetto
- ale: Allegro Vivace
- Moderato, Quasi Marcia - Oslo Philharmonic Wind Soloists
- Minuetto - Oslo Philharmonic Wind Soloists
- Andante Con Moto - Oslo Philharmonic Wind Soloists
- Allegro Molto - Oslo Philharmonic Wind Soloists
- Notturno In B Major, Op. 40
- Five Prague Waltzes
- Polka In B Flat Major, Op. 53 A / 1
Tracks:
- I
- II
- III
- IV
- V
- VI
- VII
- Preludium (Pastorale)
- Polka
- Sousedska (Minuetto)
- Romance (Romanza)
- Fineal (Furiant)
- Andante Con Moto
- Adagio
- onderato (Alla Polacca)
- Andante
- Allegro
- Polonaise In E Flat Major
- Festival March, Op. 54
Tracks:
- King And Charcoal Burner, Overture
- Prelude To Act 1
- Prelude To Act 2
- Ballet Music From Act 3
- Overture
- Prelude To Act 2
- Infernal Dance From Act 2
- Prelude To Act 3
- Overture
- Polonaise
- Dmitrij, Overture
- Armida, Overture
Tracks:
- Vanda (Overture), Op. 25
- In Nature's Realm (Overture), Op. 91
- Carnival (Overture), Op. 92
- Othello (Overture), Op. 93
- My Home (Overture), Op. 62
Tracks:
- Hussite Overture, Op. 67
- Selma Seklak Overture, Op. 37
- Dramatic Overture, Op. Posth
- Scherzo Capriccioso, Op. 66
- A Hero's Son, Op. 111
Customer Reviews:
20 Hours of Dvorak at a Bargain Price.......2004-08-03
There are numerous participants in these recordings, many of them orchestras in the Czecho-Slovak area, as well as the Polish National Radio Orchestra, the Russian Philharmonic and even London's Royal Philharmonic (in a smashing performance, with Maria Kliegel, sure one of our best current cellists, in the Cello Concerto). Conductors include Gunzenhauser, Antoni Wit, Camilla Kolchinsky, Dmitry Yablonsky, Michael Halasz, Zdenek Kosler, Libor Pesek, and Robert Stankovksy.
Obviously one wouldn't buy this set for the most familiar Dvorak pieces - the 'New World' Symphony, the Cello Concerto, the Slavonic Dances - if that was all one was interested in. There are too many fine performances of those already on the market. But how many of you have recordings of poorly known but top-drawer works like the 'Czech Suite,' the 'American Suite,' (it is fashionable to dismiss this suite, but it's actually one of Dvorak's best), or some of the orchestral music from his many operas--overtures to 'King and Charcoal Burner,' 'The Jacobin,' 'Kate and the Devil,' 'Rusalka'? All of these, and more, are here. I recently returned from a trip and the only music I took along was this box of Dvorak. I never got sated, or bored, by it.
I was also quite taken by the performance of one of my favorite pieces by Dvorak, his 'Wind Serenade,' here played by the Oslo Philharmonic Wind Soloists. And there are marvelous performances by Gunzenhauser and the Polish NRSO of 'The Noon Witch,' 'The Golden Spinning Wheel,' and (a particular favorite of mine) 'The Wild Dove.'
And then there's the super-bargain Naxos price. This is an easy recommendation for the music lover in the market for this specific collection of music.
Scott Morrison
Average customer rating:
|
Escalay: The Water Wheel
Hamza El Din Manufacturer: Nonesuch ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B000005IW8 Release Date: 1998-01-13 |
Tracks:
- The Water Wheel
- I Remember
- Song With Tar
Amazon.com
One of the first world-music releases to reach Western ears (originally issued in 1968), this album rightfully established Hamza El Din as one of the leading instrumentalists on the lutelike oud, which he taught to guitarist Sandy Bull and others. The three tracks that comprise this disc, all lengthy improvisations, showcase El Din's remarkably fluid technique and his Nubian roots, whether on the traditional "Song with Tar" or "I Remember," which was originally performed by Egypt's greatest diva, Om Kalthoum. Perhaps the best example of El Din's instrumental meditations, however, is the title track, which is his own composition. Its lines ripple and sway, then stop to ponder and work around a phrase before moving on--a style unique at the time, but which influenced a generation of oud players that followed. A masterpiece. --Chris NicksonCustomer Reviews:
ESCALAY's oud features Nubian classical traditions........2004-09-02
A specialty item for avid oud enthusiasts.
The Soul of Nubia.......2002-10-15
If you appreciate the music of Africa and/or the Middle East, then check this CD out. Its well worth the buy, and is likely unlike anything you've ever heard.
Pure Beauty~!.......2002-07-17
I just love it.......2001-08-10
slight disappointment.......2001-03-09
Average customer rating:
|
Dvorák: Tone Poems
Manufacturer: EMI Classics ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD Similar Items:
ASIN: B0009U55Z6 Release Date: 2005-08-02 |
Tracks:
- Allegro. Ma Non Troppo
- Molto Vivace
- Lento
- Allegro, Ma Non Troppo
- Andante, Marcia Funebre
- Allegro
- Molto Vivace
- Andante
Tracks:
- Allegretto
- Andante Sostenuto E Molto Tranquillo
- Andante
- Allegro Vivo
- Andante Mesto Come Primo
- Un Poco Piu Mosso
- Allegro Vivace
Amazon.com
By 1896, Dvorák had written some of his greatest works, including nine symphonies. Back from America, he was at the height of both his fame and his compositional power. Perhaps seeking a path less traveled, he wrote these four "orchestral ballads," as he called them, in quick succession, turning from his strict symphonic style to a more narrative, operatic form. However, his choice of literary inspiration can only be explained by his ardent patriotism: the poetry of Karel Jaromir Erben, an iconic Czech national poet. Archivist of Prague and collector of folk songs, he must have had a wild, perhaps folklore-influenced imagination. The poems are relentlessly gruesome and blood-thirsty, describing cruelty, mutilation, murder, suicide, and vengeance. That these horrors were alien to the warm-hearted composer is proved by his music. Although it illustrates character, atmosphere and every mood from drama and lamentation to exuberance, it is ravishingly beautiful. Its ardent, caressing lyricism, soaring melodies, inspired harmonies, daring modulations and ecstatic climaxes are literally breath-taking. Why these towering masterpieces are so rarely heard is a mystery; it is easy to ignore the grim literary content and surrender to the music, and the masterly, colorful orchestration must make them wonderful to play as well. Recorded live, the performance is superb: grand and sweeping yet sensitive to every timbral and expressive nuance, but the extreme, often sudden dynamic contrasts require a finger on the volume control. --Edith EislerCustomer Reviews:
Musical but unexciting Dvorak.......2007-05-03
As it is, Amazon sells this as a two-for-one proposition. However, because almost every other rendition of these four works -- "The Golden Spinning Wheel", "The Wood Dove", "The Noonday Witch" and "The Water Goblin" -- you can put your hands on is more exciting than these, the value of this is significantly degraded. Most other reoordings are also more Slavic, something you probably wouldn't expect from a German orchestra and British conductor.
And they don't let you down in that regard! Rattle's attack in this music, if you dare call it that, is ultramusical and international. He eschews overstatement, both musically and emotionally, 100 percent of the time. I haven't heard hundreds of recordings of this music but every one I've heard is more exciting than these, more given to Slavic temperament, and many are just as involving from an architectural standpoint.
Rattle by contrast carries on with genial performances that emphasize individual elements of the score, almost as if he's tending too much to the trees and not enough to the forest This is fine as far as it goes but it leaves too much out of the music and basically misses the big picture.
These exact four tone poems were released on another twofer by Harnoncourt a few years back that received plentiful critical plaudits and are still considered de rigeur interpretations in the Penguin Guide (even though the disks have apparently been withdrawn in USA). Other remarkable recordings have been turned in by Czech conductors Talich, Chalabala, and Kubelik. Some notable non-Slavs have done them too -- Jarvi, Gunzenhauser,and American Theodore Kuchar -- to some or great acclaim.
In addition I note the same marketing shortcoming as the Harnoncourt issue: Rattle and Harnoncourt put 83 minutes and 81 minutes of music, respectively, on two CDs. In the super audio era where companies can squeeze this much music on one SACD, why didn't EMI choose to do that and release this as an SACD? It would have given the recording a novelty no other could match. Furthermore, they could have marketed this as one of the reasons the Berliners chose Rattle as their conductor -- because they wanted to perform repertoire outside their historic and expected range.
Indeed, when Rattle arrived in Berlin, the story was his selection marked a turning point in the history of the great orchestra. Rattle's charge was to take the orchestra in new and different directions, both interpretively (with his penchant for period performance) and in terms of repertory. This recording was a chance to capitalize on all that. It now appears to be an opportunity lost.
Rare music.......2007-01-20
Harnoncourt, Mackerras, Jarvi, Kertesz, and Kubelik all better Rattle's readings.......2006-09-01
Lacking in character.......2006-07-03
What I find cruelly lacking in Rattle's approach is his reluctance to take any risks, avoiding all dramatic tension with a Berlin Philharmonic appearing stiffer and more immovable than ever. Too much is taken for granted here - the luxurious sound machine included - and that's exactly what this music doesn't need. Dvorak's poems need character before anything (recently, Nikolaus Harnoncourt with the superior Concertgebouw Orchestra perfectly understood that - just compare his "Water Goblin" with Rattle's). As Andrew Huth in the excellent liner notes with this CD explains, Dvorak "was always anxious to be appreciated as a Czech artist" - and these symphonic poems are prime examples of Czech culture. Rattle and his plush but in the end rather impersonal orchestra deliver very little in that respect, neither in spirit nor in sound, though. It's big, loud, and far too superficial, not helped by the rather undefined recording quality secured by the EMI engineers. Disappointing.
Reveling in the sound of a great orchestra.......2006-03-05
The music is well-described in the other reviews. Dvorak, to my mind, tended to do a better job with the open-ended format of these tone poems than he sometimes did with symphonic form. Perhaps he felt less constrained. In any event, these tone poems are indeed top-drawer Dvorak, and less known than they should be.
A couple of reviews in the major publications have been critical of Rattle's interpretation of these works. That's fair. As with Rattle's Debussy disc, from time to time he seems to become absorbed in the beauty of the individual moment, in the process letting the pulse drift and losing the thread of the musical architecture.
But I have to admit that he's a master at making the most out of the beauty of the individual moment, and with the Berlin Philharmonic, has a superb vehicle with which to do it.
As with the Debussy disc, the recording seems to me to be excellent, although I have to agree with others that the exceptionally wide dynamic range in some quiet spots almost causes you to wonder where the sound went. (It's entirely possible, though, that part of that is Rattle's doing--it is entirely consistent with, for example, his recording of Sibelius's 4th Symphony with Birmingham years ago.) What I particularly like, though, is how different the orchestra sounds with EMI versus DG. I hear more individual detail in the EMI recordings; a more close-in perspective, and less of a glossy homogenous sheen on the strings. (This is not to dis the DG "style"--I really enjoyed the sound on DG's recent Abbado Pelleas excerpts disc as well--although some of the Karajan efforts suffered from "too much of a good thing.")
So, one could ask for performances with more forward motion and coherence, but, when the playing and sound of the orchestra are this good, there is some real listening pleasure to be had.
Average customer rating:
|
Dvorák: Complete Symphonic Poems
Manufacturer: Chandos ProductGroup: Music Binding: Audio CD ASIN: B000000AJV Release Date: 1992-10-28 |
Tracks:
- My Home, Ov Op.62
- The Water Goblin, Symphonic Poem Op.107
- The Golden Spinning Wheel, Symphonic Poem Op.109
Tracks:
- The Noon Witch, Symphonic Poem Op.108
- The Wood Dove, Symphonic Poem Op.110
- The Hero's Song, Symphonic Poem Op.111
Amazon.com
With Rafael Kubelik's classic performances on DG shamefully out of print, this is just about the only show in town for Dvorák's symphonic poems. Fortunately, they are very fine performances, marred only by the slightly overreverberant recording in a couple of works. Purely from the musical standpoint, Neeme Järvi's extremely direct, exciting conducting suits these colorful and dramatic works very well. It's also great to have the last and most neglected of the five, Heroic Song, included for a change. It's no less enjoyable than the other four, and only the fact that it's not based on a folk tale has prevented it from receiving the attention it deserves. A fine set. - -David HurwitzCustomer Reviews:
Arguably the Definitive Set of Dvorak Symphonic Poems.......2005-01-12
Meditation Music:
- Whisper Me
- Women of Ireland, Pt. 1
- 801 Live [Live]
- A Different Shore
- A Higher Place
- A Musical Mirage: Oceans of Light
- Album 2
- Another Sun
- Aras
- At Peace
Meditation Music
Music Review: 100 % Black V.4 [Import]
Nocturne / Aubade / Feuillet D'Album
Music: Clementi: Piano Trios Op. 28 / Op. 32
Quanto Mais Curtido Melhor [Import]
Nights of the Iguana [Box set] [Import]